Cara Winter: The Anglo Files 5

sherlock meme (1)

Martin Freeman as Watson and Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock.

On Sherlock Holmes
by Cara Winter

As we all know, since 2010 two shows (CBS’ Elementary, and the BBC’s Sherlock, which has also been picked up by PBS Masterpiece) have reimagined Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s famous detective Sherlock Holmes within a modern setting.   As a writer trying to modernize a Victorian piece myself, I have been wondering  why, exactly, one of these modernizations has set the world on fire… while the other is just on?

It all starts with the fact that the BBC’s version came first.  In 2012, when CBS (as has been reported here and here) approached creators Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss about remaking Sherlock in America, Moffat & Gatiss politely declined.  Smartly, CBS chose not to embroil themselves in a legal battle by ripping off Sherlock whole-hog… and instead did everything they could to make their take on a “modern Sherlock Holmes” really, really different from Sherlock.

I get it, I do. CBS wanted to move forward; Sherlock Holmes was sexy, all of a sudden.  Who wouldn’t want to capitalize on that?  But, as all Moffat and Gatiss really did was move the characters and stories they loved into our century, creator Robert Doherty would have to change more than just the ol’ anno domini.  (By the way, his show Medium?  Genius.  So, I know he’s likely not the problem…)

So change, they did.  But… at what expense?  If you’ve ever watched Elementary for more than five minutes, well, you know…  it isn’t ground breaking.  It’s a pretty standard network cop show, with a huge budget and all the pretty pretty things.  (A Sherlock Holmes purist might say they ruined it.  Which I am not.  A purist, that is.)   But, how?   How did this happen?  Well, apologies to my lawyer friends (sorry guys!)… but my money’s on the lawyers.  The writers probably wrote a hundred drafts, and each time CBS’ lawyers said “no”, for fear of being sued (which was justified, as they were, you know, running with an idea that wasn’t theirs to begin with).

Still, even with a possible lawsuit looming, methinks they could have done more to capture the heart of the original Sherlock Holmes stories.

Starting with:

  1. Location, location, location

Elementary is set in New York City.  Hmm.  Concerning.  Because Sherlock Holmes’s address is 221B Baker Street.   It just is.  There isn’t even a Baker Street in New York City.

I’m kidding, of course; it’s not the address.  It’s that, even at home, Sherlock is an outsider.  Holmes doesn’t fit in to the one place he’s supposed to fit into.  That makes Sherlock Holmes’ relationship to ‘home’ tricky, and layered, and very important to his story. (Which, in turn, makes ‘home’ one of the characters in the story.)

By making Holmes an ex-pat living in New York, Elementary has completely ruined this lovely, all-important layer.   One could argue (and I do!) that if they wanted to set it in New York, make Holmes a New Yorker!  That way, the larger point could be conveyed that even when Sherlock Holmes is at home, he doesn’t quite fit in.

Which leads me to my next point:

  1. A Fine Bromance

In CBS’ Elementary, Dr. Watson is a woman.   Now, trust me, I love to see great women characters on TV.   But… the beauty of the Holmes/Watson relationship is that they are both men.  I’m sorry, it just is.  Blame it on societal conventions, or Sunday Night Football, or the whole of Christianity if you want.  Fact is, we live in a world where dudes aren’t supposed to be so fond of each other – yet Holmes and Watson are.  Sherlock gets this right, and as their friendship grows, it’s very moving and powerful to watch.

By making Dr. Watson a woman, Elementary has cut us off at the knees.   There are other gender roles you could play with; make Lestrade a woman, or give Sherlock two mommies!  Something!  Don’t change The Great Original Bromance, arguably the first and finest ever created, the one relationship which lies at the very heart of the whole thing.

(And not for nothing, there also seems to be absolutely zero chemistry between Lucy Liu and Johnny Lee Miller.  They’re both cute, but they treat each other like strangers!   Conversely, the chemistry between Freeman and Cumberbatch is electrifying.  Come to think of it, everyone seems to have palpable chemistry with The Batch.  Oh, for a walk-on…)

But I digress.

  1. Laughter Is the Best Medicine

Moffat & Gatiss (or “MoffGat”, as I like to call them) have loved Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s stories since childhood.  Their genuine joy for the work, therefore, comes through in the final product.  (Imagine that!)  And everyone involved with the show seems to share that love, and also have a sense of humor about what they’re doing (making telly, not curing cancer!).  As a result… Sherlock is funny. Very funny.

Elementary …is not funny.  I can’t even put my finger on why; it’s just all as serious as an E.R. heart attack.  Or, a 24 heart attack.   It’s as if Elementary is made by children trying to seem grown up, whereas Sherlock is made by grownups who enjoy life as though they’re still children.

Great adaptations take care, they take love, and they take a deep understanding of the source material.  And, as in any story (original or adapted), locations matter, but they matter because of how they inform the characters.  Relationships matter even more; relationships must be clear and universal, and most of all meaningful to the story.  And for the love of all that’s holy, let us laugh!  If you can get your audience laughing, they’ll care, and then they’ll follow you to the ends of the earth.  Or, if not to the ends of the earth, at least as far as PBS.

PS:  Fellow writers, it was very enlightening to examine these two shows side by side.  Next time you find a show “meh”, wait before you change the channel… see if you can figure out why.


Cara Winter is a Contributing Editor to TVWriter™. You can learn more about her HERE.

About Cara Winter

Born & raised in Kalamazoo, MI (yes, there really is a Kalamazoo). Living, writing & raising a son in Chicago, IL. BFA in Acting from New York University / Tisch School of the Arts. Professional stage actress for 20 years; member, Actor's Equity Association Writing for the stage since 2000.